Image by Brett Boardman
E.M Forster's novel had a perfectly cast film about 40 years ago, with early roles for Helena Bonham Carter, Daniel Day-Lewis and Julian Sands, alongside Maggie Smith, Judi Dench, Simon Callow and Denholm Elliot, with fine location photography and a passionate soundtrack. But in Grace Chappelle's adaptation, it gains in intimacy what it slightly loses in spectacle, with a cast that holds their own against their illustrious predecessors. Forster's novel looks at an Edwardian young woman whose travels in Italy open her up to new perspectives that startle her and discovers that maybe her conventional background does not need to shape the rest of her life.
Chapple's adaptation rotates the narrative voice around the cast, with various figures commenting on Lucy's journey from her uptight travelling companion Charlotte to an Italian carriage driver to Lucy's snobbish rebound guy, Cecil Vyse, and also interrogates some of the values underpinning the material - in particular, Forster's life as a closeted gay man gets reflected in the material (just as it was in the last big stage Forster's adaptation, The Inheritance) - as does elements of Forster's own reflections on English culture and politics. There's also a very Belvoir approach to staging - Hannah Goodwin uses elements of music by Grace Ferguson and loose play, with the assistance of Elle Evangilista's choreography, in constantly surprising in her storytelling. The set is a relatively wall of doors and windows, designed by Zoe Atkinson, that has a few bonus twists up its sleeves.
The cast are a solid ensemble of performers, with all cast members getting at least one key role as well as blending into the ensemble. Nathalie Morris is a compelling heroine, with a sense of idealism balanced with nervousness about wandering off the beaten path, with Luke Wiltshire being suitably compelling as her suitor George, and Charles Wu inhabiting the snobbish ridiculousness of Cecil admirably. Tomas Kantor is playful as her brother Freddie and Tom Conroy is a delightfully reserved Reverend Beebe. Hayley McElhinney delights in all of Charlotte's perskitiness and joy of gossip, and Kate Atkinson enjoys her distracted authoress Mrs Lavish and her generous Mrs Honeychurch about equally. And Patrick Williams has a nicely zen quality as the ethical Mr Emerson who's open-ness provokes so much from other people
In short this is a delightful telling of a classic romance with a bit more depth behind it than may be expected- it's a show that goes for the heart and embraces it in looking at what freedom may in fact mean (including a just-after-the-happy ending moment that makes the not-entirely-romantic-consequences of the character's choices obvious, along with ways that those choices are not open to everyone). It's a nice feat for the heart and the brain.






